SONG OF THE SOUTH

When Belfast City Council voted to break with tradition in 2012 by reducing the flying of the Union Flag atop City Hall from 365 to 18 days a year, the more vociferous wing of the Unionist community greeted the announcement with violent protests. A couple of days ago, marking the anniversary of the Battle of the Boyne, bonfires were lit across Unionist strongholds of the province, many of which were decorated with photos of prominent Sinn Fein politicians. I only nod to our neighbours over the Irish Sea to make a roundabout point on how the issues that enflame passions on both sides of the sectarian divide in Northern Ireland barely register on the mainland; they’re viewed by the rest of the UK (with the possible exception of Glasgow) as parochial concerns unique to Ulster and characteristic of a land with an extremely long memory.

Even with the high profile suddenly afforded the DUP in the wake of Theresa May’s golden handshake, the ‘street politics’ of Northern Ireland rarely attract outsiders to the barricades, something that can’t be said of another divided community from a region with a similarly turbulent history several thousand miles away – Virginia. The dramatic and ugly events that took place in Charlottesville, Virginia at the weekend didn’t have their source material in religious divisions, but race – the most contentious of all American issues that just won’t go away. Not even eight years of a black President could sort it.

Virginia was one of the four slave states from the ‘Upper South’ of the US that, along with Arkansas, Tennessee and North Carolina, joined the original seven Southern secessionist states in the Confederacy during the Civil War. Its history, now so bound-up with the Confederacy and its aftermath, predates that era considerably, with Virginia being the first English colony in the New World, established as far back as 1607. But it was also prominent among the 13 colonies that broke with British rule and has a claim as being the birthplace of the USA; it certainly was the birthplace of eight US Presidents, for one thing.

Like the rest of the states in the South, Virginia had a segregationist policy in place until the civil rights movement of the 1960s gradually led to a repeal of the remaining Jim Crow laws; but its past, like many of its neighbours’ pasts, continues to attract the attention of those for whom integration remains a greater threat to making America great again than the hardware in Kim Jong Un’s toy-box.

Recent attempts to reduce the high visibility of the Confederate Flag in the Southern states have gone hand-in-hand with a concerted programme to remove statues of, and monuments to, Confederate heroes from public places; and these efforts at erasing a history that sits uncomfortably on the shoulders of modern America have served to ignite the ire of white Southern natives proud of their inheritance, as well as white supremacists from different parts of the country who exploit the situation to promote their cause. When Washington belatedly addressed the iniquities and inequality of the South in the 60s by outlawing its segregationist traditions, the white population claimed the rest of the US didn’t understand the South and there’s probably a grain of truth in that. The South was seen as something of an embarrassment that contradicted America’s international reputation as the Land of the Free; the South was a place where the past remained present.

The ongoing contemporary operation to change the perception of the South, not only for outsiders but also for those who live there, has been characterised by the official removal of ‘negative’ symbols relating to its past; though whereas the pulling down of statues during an uprising or revolution tends to come from the emancipated population itself, the policy of removing them that has been taking place across the South of late is a decision of federal government. Many have viewed this decision as symptomatic of rewriting American history, a rewrite that fails to acknowledge aspects of it that don’t complement the image America likes to project of itself. There are also concerns that by erasing the visible legacy of the Confederacy, future generations are being presented with a lopsided story of their country, one without warts and all, and one depriving them of a history they could learn from.

Plans to remove a statue of Robert E Lee, Confederate Civil War general, in Charlottesville led to the town being invaded on Saturday by a ‘Unite the Right’ march, bringing in angry white men from all over America for a rally that was destined to be met with a counter-rally. Whatever valid points had a right to be made didn’t stand a chance of being heard; both sides were infiltrated by those whose intentions were obvious from the start, many of whom had little or nothing to do with the part of the country they headed for.

The relatively liberal college town of Charlottesville was hijacked by opposing sides looking for a battlefield. The far-from spotless ‘Black Lives Matter’ crowd were accompanied by the masked men from ‘antifa’ – an abbreviation of ‘anti-fascist’ – who have a reputation as violent left-wing anarchists; they were the group responsible for the trouble that occurred in Washington on the day of Donald Trump’s inauguration. Those under the Alt-Right banner included neo-Nazis as well as that old mainstay always up for a fight, the Ku Klux Klan. The KKK are almost to the South what the Orangemen are to Ulster, though for all their shared pseudo-Masonic ritualism and shameful record of gerrymandering, the Orangemen are a long way from the Klan when it comes to provoking and stoking hatred in the most sinister manner.

What was already a predictable and unedifying clash on Saturday plumbed especially appalling depths when one lunatic ironically took a leaf out of the Jihadi manual and drove a car directly at protestors; his efforts were responsible for 19 injuries and one death. The white supremacists, who view President Trump as ‘their man’, were gratified that the Donald seemed reluctant to attribute blame for events to them, though the majority of the Alt Right (to whom Trump owes a great debt) probably regard the extremists who descended upon Charlottesville with the same abhorrence as the left views the ‘antifa’. It would certainly suit the narrative of the moment to lump together anyone who questions or challenges the anti-Trump consensus into one hate-fuelled, racist mob; but unfortunately, it’s not quite so…erm…black and white.

© The Editor

11 thoughts on “SONG OF THE SOUTH

  1. This was a very interesting event which I have followed in some detail. As ever, what you see and hear on the TV and what actually happened are very far apart.
    I understand that the riot took place on George Soros’ 87th birthday. I am sure he had a very happy one.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. He is quite active. He started his career by actively assisting Nazis round up Jews, and there is an interview circulating in which he describes this as one of the happiest times of his life. But I think the real question is not who he is, but what he is.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. And, at the same time, we’re invited every day by the BBC to ‘celebrate’ the 70th anniversary of some more rioting and massacre, with at least a million dead, which took place under the guise of religious geography rather than race, but which continues to bedevil the India/Pakistan relationship, and all of their citizens, to this day. An elderly ‘Pakistani’ friend of mine reacts uncharacteristically strongly when I remind him that he’s actually Indian, having been born and initially raised in India before Pakistan existed – I’ve only to say in jest “You Indians are all the same……” and his hackles rise.

    I suspect that the currently increased visibility of ‘white supremacists’ in the USA is directly connected to Trump’s election. Rather like Brexit, his elevation is attributed to a coalescing of the ‘unheard majority’, those many millions who had seen their nation change in directions they did not like, but no-one was listening to them or pleading their cause for decades. Indeed, simply being heard to plead that cause publicly brought opprobrium in volume from all the right-on establishment so, when finally given a ballot-box opportunity to kick back in private, that’s what they did in both cases.
    And now they have been heard, their extreme wings can also feel able to take their message to the streets – given the type of folk they are at the extremities, then levels of violence would seem almost inevitable. (Mrs May would be wise to note that consequence.)
    But, in the same way that the authorities have long sought to assuage the feelings of those other disadvantaged groups who have expressed their views strongly, the same authorities now need to work out what’s the least they can do to make these new ‘victims’, the white supremacists, more satisfied with their lot whilst, at the same time, not upsetting those others to whom they had been exclusively pandering for the last half-century. Tricky call, but no-one ever said governing was easy.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’ve toyed with the notion of penning a ‘partition’ post, as it’s as significant a piece of British as Indian history – especially the timing of it, hot on the heels of the terrible 1947 winter that stretched the country to breaking point.

      Like

      1. i just think it’s hilarious that the Cork supporters’ club guy basically says (granted, I’m paraphrasing a little) “our supporters aren’t racists. They are just too stupid to understand the connotations of the Confederacy flag” 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Another interesting and rather odd connection that springs to mind is that the Tyrone gaelic football supporters’ flag is somewhat similar to the logo used by the Red Hand Defenders (the loyalist terrorist organisation mentioned in the piece above^)…but the vast majority of GAA supporters in Northern Ireland are from a nationalist/republican background, and the relatively small number who hail from a unionist background certainly wouldn’t be fans of the likes of the Red Hand Defenders.

    https://www.google.ie/search?q=tyrone+gaa&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjA7Pru2dfVAhXGDsAKHW1uBS4Q_AUICygC&biw=1366&bih=659

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Here’s another odd one.

    Cork is the only place on this planet I’ve ever seen someone wearing a football jersey with ‘Sands 66’ emblazoned on the back (circa 1995/1996 – some of the nineties were a bit hazy for me).

    God, the world is confusing.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. If you want a radical re-appraisal of the relationship between the Democratic party and slavery find a lecture by Denesh D’Souza on youtube. There are many, but one could start with one called “The Democrats have always been the party of Racism.” Admittedly a Reaganite, he nevertheless to my mind he establishes quite clearly that the Democratic party was always the party with the closest association with slavery and thuggery, including the KKK.

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.